On Negative Book Reviews

I recently came across an article about tagging authors on social media for bad book reviews from The Guardian and wanted to discuss the topic further. The article specifically mentions YA author Angie Thomas (author of The Hate U Give), who recently posted this on Twitter:


Since this post went up, Thomas has been attacked for her desire to not be tagged for negative reviews. The hate has come from Twitter mentions, Facebook groups, and other platforms. As Read Yourself Happy focuses on, well, being happy, I’m not going to show or quote the hateful comments here, because it would serve absolutely no purpose. Suffice it to say, the people now targeting Angie Thomas are doing so on the following bases:

  • Authors are public figures and as such should not be able to dictate who tags them and why
  • Thomas is somehow being rude for requesting such a thing (I really don’t understand this argument at all)
  • Let’s ban her books because ALL THE ANGER.

Here’s how I feel about this drama: the internet is already a crude and hateful place. Is it really necessary to let authors know that you don’t like their work? Would you go up to them in person and tell them you hated their book? You probably wouldn’t. So, do you need to tag the author on Twitter in your one-star review? No, you don’t.

If an author doesn’t want to be attacked on social media, that’s their right. Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram are constantly full of drama that is 100% unnecessary.

For authors that do want to read negative reviews, all they have to do is Google themselves. I’ve had authors find my negative reviews and comment on them. It’s not hard for them to find.

How to Handle Writing Negative Reviews

As a book reviewer, I’ve written plenty of bad reviews. I never tag authors in my Twitter links, however. I only tag an author if I’ve given them a four or five-star rating because at that point I’m complimenting them. Just like I wouldn’t walk up to Stephen King and say, “Hey, I thought your novel Elevation was trash!”, I also wouldn’t @ him on Twitter to say the same thing.

There’s nothing wrong with writing bad book reviews. After all, book reviews are for other readers more than anyone else. You absolutely should share your bookish opinions.

If you want to post a link to your social media account, you still can! Just don’t @ the author! If you must, you can use a hashtag (such as, #angiethomas), which means you’re not actually notifying the author that you hated their book, you’re just making it easier for people curious about their work to find your review.

Authors and anyone else in the public eye are real, actual people with feelings. Don’t be a dick. Be nice on social media and make the internet better for everyone, please.

If you want to read a different opinion on the topic, here’s an article that was posted over at Book Riot.

What do you think? Should you tag authors in bad reviews? Why or why not? Let me know in the comments.

Don’t forget to follow me on social media:

Twitter | Facebook | Goodreads | Pinterest | Instagram | Amazon Wishlist

If you would like to support Read Yourself Happy, you can donate through Ko-Fi!

6 thoughts on “On Negative Book Reviews”

  1. I absolutely think that you shouldn’t tag authors in bad reviews. I don’t tag authors in any reviews, but that’s more due to my anxiety about interacting with authors. But a review isn’t for an author; it’s for other readers. We are not giving constructive criticism; the books already done and that ship has sailed. There’s no reason to tell someone you hated their book except to hurt them. I feel so bad for Angie Thomas for what she’s going through, and any author who’s been through this.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I completely agree with you. Negative reviews aren’t for the author, they’re for other people to read and determine if the book is for them DESPITE some of the things that other people didn’t like about it.
    Honestly, I feel like a lot of it comes with not seeing them as people. I’ve met several of the authors that I’m constantly reading and reviewing and I can’t imagine how I would have felt when I met them had I known that they’d read some terribly negative reviews about their novels that I’d written.
    Such a great post that I feel like all book bloggers should be required to read.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Yeah my younger self was definitely guilty of this but I’m definitely more mindful of this now. I know that I wouldn’t what to be bombarded with that kind of negativity everyday. I do believe in negative reviews though, I dont think I should pick and choose which books I review based on my enjoyment.

    Brilliant viewpoint. Xo

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I agree with you. There is no reason to tag an author in a negative review. They aren’t going to go back and republish the book fixing whatever your negative review is about. How much on person enjoys or does not enjoy a book is purely based on that person. I have read many books that I did not like but others absolutely love. Authors don’t need to see day in and day out the bad reviews, they would never write again. You’re right, you can write a bad review but at the end of the day it is about treating people with respect and dignity.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s